You’re standing in front of the dummy shelf. Butterflies, cherries, “orthodontic”, “natural”, “night-time”, glow-in-the-dark… Meanwhile, the baby at home clearly has opinions, because yesterday they spat out all three you already own. 😅
If you feel a bit lost, that’s completely understandable. The choice looks complicated, but only a handful of things really matter. The rest is a matter of taste – mostly the baby’s.
Don’t worry, we’ll go through them one by one.
Does my baby actually need a dummy?
No, it’s optional. Some babies love one, others want nothing to do with it, and that’s perfectly fine. If your baby spits it out, don’t push – the AAP (American Academy of Pediatrics) specifically advises not to force a baby to take one.
According to the NHS, you can think about using a dummy to settle your baby to sleep, because some research suggests it may help lower the risk of SIDS (sudden infant death syndrome). The AAP also suggests offering it at nap time and bedtime. You’ll find the other key rules in our guide Safe Sleep: Simple Rules That Lower the Risk of SIDS.
When should I offer one if I’m breastfeeding?
The AAP suggests waiting until breastfeeding is going well – usually about 3 to 4 weeks. The reason is simple: early on, the breast needs lots of sucking to set up your milk supply. If you bottle-feed, this works a little differently.
And one more thing: a dummy doesn’t replace a feed. Offer it when you’re sure your baby isn’t hungry.
Which shape: orthodontic or classic cherry?
- Classic (round, “cherry”): looks like a bottle teat and many babies take to it easily.
- Orthodontic (flattened, angled): according to the Lullaby Trust, as cited by the NCT, it adapts to the baby’s mouth and may be kinder to teeth.
The honest answer: there’s no winner. The AAP suggests trying different shapes until you find the one your baby prefers. So don’t buy a ten-pack of the same one straight away.
Read alsoBaby playpen: do you need one and how to choose a safe oneHigh chairs: how to choose
Buy one dummy in 2–3 different shapes before committing to a brand. Your baby will vote with their mouth – and the vote is usually very clear. 😊
What should I check on the dummy itself?
- One single piece: the AAP recommends a one-piece model with a soft teat – some multi-piece designs can come apart.
- A wide shield with air holes: the shield (the plastic part around the teat) should be at least 1½ inches (about 3.8 cm) across, so your baby can’t fit the whole dummy in their mouth, and made of firm plastic with air holes.
- Size for age: dummies are sold by age range – check the label.
- EN 1400: this is the European safety standard for dummies. Look for it on the pack.
- Dishwasher-safe: the AAP suggests checking this too.
Silicone or latex?
These are the two most common materials. Latex (natural rubber) is usually softer and stretchier, while silicone is firmer and easier to clean. Some babies have a clear favourite, others couldn’t care less. If you’re unsure whether a material suits your baby, ask your health visitor, GP or pharmacist.
Dummy clips: yes or no?
A clip is a lifesaver on walks (especially over puddles). But the AAP is clear on one point: never tie a dummy to the cot, or around your baby’s neck or hand. If you use a clip, choose a short one that fastens to clothing and is marked EN 12586, the European standard. For sleep – no clips or cords in the cot.
How do I clean it and when should I replace it?
- Before first use: boil it or run it through the dishwasher, following the instructions. Then squeeze the water out of the teat with clean hands – hot water trapped inside could burn your baby’s mouth.
- Until 6 months: the AAP suggests cleaning it this way often.
- After 6 months: washing with soap and rinsing in clean water is enough.
- Check it regularly: if the rubber has changed colour or torn, replace it. Some manufacturers also give an expiry date.
- Don’t use a bottle teat as a dummy: with strong sucking it can pop out of the ring.
Keep 3–4 dummies in strategic spots: the changing bag, the car, next to the cot. Dummies vanish at a mysterious rate – there’s probably a whole planet of them somewhere. 🌿
More ideas on what’s worth buying (and what isn’t) are waiting in Best Products & Reviews.
What about teeth and speech?
According to the AAP, strong sucking beyond 2 to 4 years of age may affect the shape of the mouth and how the teeth line up. The NCT’s review notes that stopping by around age two has been recommended to protect the teeth. On speech, research is mixed: any effect seems small and is linked to many hours of daytime use. That’s why many families gradually keep the dummy for sleep only.
For dads
Become the “Chief Dummy Officer”: you sterilise them, check for tears and make sure there’s always a spare in the bag. It sounds small, but at 3am, when the only dummy is under the cot, you’ll be a hero.
When to ask your health visitor or GP?
If your baby struggles to suck, isn’t gaining weight well, or you have questions about teeth or speech, talk to your health visitor, GP or a children’s dentist. They know your baby and can help you decide calmly.
In short
A good dummy is one piece, has a wide shield with air holes, fits your baby’s age and is kept clean. Your baby picks the shape; you take care of safety. Don’t panic if the first one is rejected – even the best relationships start with a few “no thank yous”. You’re doing better than you think. 💛
Sources: NHS – Reduce the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS); AAP / HealthyChildren.org – Pacifiers & Thumb Sucking: What Parents Need to Know; NCT – Dummies, pros and cons: your dummy questions answered.


